ECODESIGN EEG PILOT

Checklist for ECODESIGN analysis

Product

Do you meet the overall recovery rate of 75%? Do you meet the reuse and recycling rate of 65%?
  
  
What is your current recovery rate? Which parts of the product are problematic to recover? Which measures will presumably improve recovery - the reuse of components and the recycling of materials in particular?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Meeting set recovery rates for consumer electronics
Idea for
Realization


Is the symbol which indicates separate collection of electrical and electronic equipment visible, legible and indelible? Are both manufacturer and date of manufacture stated?
  
  
Where is the symbol located? By which means is it affixed? How can you make sure that the symbol remains indelibly legible?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Standard-compliant marking of electrical and electronic equipment
Idea for
Realization


Is waste being collected separately, using an existing collection system?
  
  
Which collection systems exist? Who runs them? Is the collection of waste being handled efficiently? Is it purposeful to set up your own collection system?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Separate collection of electrical and electronic equipment
Idea for
Realization


Is it feasible to remove all fluids and hazardous substances from the waste device?
  
  
To which extent do you consider the processing of waste equipment satisfactory? Who is in charge of the processing? Is all necessary data on hazardous substances in the product available? Which substances and components must absolutely be removed from the device?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Selective treatment: removal of fluids and hazardous substances
Idea for
Realization


Is it possible to easily remove components which contain critical substances from the waste device?
  
  
To which extent do you consider the processing of waste equipment satisfactory? Which components must absolutely be removed from the device? Can this be done without difficulty.
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Selective treatment: removal of components which contain hazardous substances
Idea for
Realization


Is the reuse of waste being facilitated by employing specific construction or manufacturing processes?
  
  
What are the impacts of alternative utilization concepts on the design and manufacturing of products? Which requirements need to be given consideration? How can these requirements be accounted for by means of constructional features?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Product concepts
Idea for
Realization


Do you provide the user with sufficient information as to the separate collection of devices and contained hazardous substances?
  
  
Which information do you supply along with the electro device? Do you supply information which adverts to the obligation to separately collect EEE waste? Do you point to potential adverse effects of hazardous substances contained in a product? Do you explain the meaning of the symbol required by ANNEX IV?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure End-user information
Idea for
Realization


Do you supply sufficient information on contained components and on the exact location of hazardous substances and preparations?
  
  
Do you provide information on components and materials contained in a product? Do you specify the parts of a product which contain hazardous substances and preparations?
Relevance (R) Fulfillment (F) Priority (P)
very important ( 10 )
less important ( 5 )
not relevant ( 0 )
yes ( 1 )
rather yes ( 2 )
rather no ( 3 )
no ( 4 )

P = R * F
Measure Information for treatment facilities
Idea for
Realization



Approach to assessment:
  1. Relevance:
    Rate the relevance of the assessment question with a view to your product. (10...very important for my product; 5...less important for my product; 0...not relevant for my product).
  2. Fullfilment:
    Estimate the fulfilment of the assessment questions using one of the four possible answers (yes / rather yes / rather no / no); the additional questions support understanding of the assessment question and need not be answered.
  3. Priority:
    Select ECODESIGN tasks with high priority (P) and continue only with these.
  4. Idea for Realization:
    Find ideas to realize these ECODESIGN tasks. The content of the learning part with its examples shall assist you in doing that.
  5. Save:
    Save the checklist to document the ECODESIGN assessment.

 

top design & copyright © VUT, Institute for Engineering Design - ECODESIGN

Meeting set recovery rates for consumer electronics

Article 7 of the WEEE Directive sets the recovery rate for category 4 devices to an overall 75% of average weight per appliance. This is to be interpreted as the recovery of any type of material or energy. The mandatory reuse and recycling rate for components, materials and substances is set to 65% of a device's average weight.

The coatings of tubes in TV sets and their getters are considered hazardous waste. A mechanical separation of glass and metal components, as well as the suction removal of coatings and their ecologically sound treatment cause considerable costs.


Standard-compliant marking of electrical and electronic equipment

Manufacturers and importers are required to mark electrical and electronic devices which enter the market after August 13, 2005, with the WEEE symbol "crossed-out wheeled bin indicating separate collection of electrical and electronic equipment." The symbol must be printed visibly, legibly and indelibly. In exceptional cases (e.g. small size), the symbol shall be printed on the packaging, on the instructions for use and/or on the warranty of the product. With the exception of the CE-mark, medical devices shall not bear further marking. Therefore, the WEEE symbol must be printed on the packaging, etc., of such devices. To facilitate a separate handling of older single-manufacturer devices, manufacturers shall provide for the identification of devices put on the market after August 13, 2005. This shall be realized by specifying the manufacturer and the date of manufacture.


Separate collection of electrical and electronic equipment

A separate collection is prerequisite for the specific treatment and recycling of electrical and electronic equipment. According to Article 5 of WEEE, manufacturers are obliged to take back returned waste equipment. This obligation can be met in various ways. Waste equipment can either be returned to the manufacturer directly and free of charge, or disposed of through collective take-back systems. The latter is compulsory for historical EEE waste. Older devices from private households can be returned to the distributor (>150m2 sales floor) free of charge when purchasing an equivalent new device. The collection of commercially used waste EEE must be provided for by manufacturers or third parties acting on their behalf. Two take-back points per administrative district shall be established for distributors using distance selling channels.
Further information on collection systems


Selective treatment: removal of fluids and hazardous substances

In accordance with Article 6, hazardous substances from separately collected EEE waste shall be removed in order to forestall the release or transfer of such substances. Some electro waste, on the other hand, is abundant with valuable recyclables, such as copper wire in external electrical leads, which can be recovered and reused. To comply with the WEEE Directive, at least all fluids and hazardous substances shall be removed from waste equipment, as stated in ANNEX II.These substances and fluids include: CFC, HCFC, HFC and hydrocarbons (HC). Among other applications, hazardous substances can be found in:

Selective treatment: removal of components which contain hazardous substances

In accordance with Article 6, components which contain hazardous substances must be removed from electro waste. Such components are e.g.:

Detailed information on components which need to be removed is available in ANNEX II. Processing standards are specified for a selection of components. The fluorescent coating of cathode ray tubes, for example, must be removed.


Product concepts

According to WEEE's Article 4, manufacturers are to facilitate the reuse of waste electro equipment by avoiding obstructive design features or manufacturing processes. Exempt from this provision are features and processes which are clearly favorable as to pollution control and safety regulations. Hence, the dismantling and recovery of electro equipment - its reuse and recycling in particular - are to be considered and facilitated right from the beginning of the design stage of new electrical and electronic products.


End-user information

Article 10 of the WEEE Directive states that private household users of electro devices shall be adverted both to the obligation to separately collect electro waste and to currently available return and collection systems. In view of this necessity, manufacturers need to explain the meaning of the crossed-out wheeled bin symbol required by ANNEX IV. Additionally, producers are called on to emphasize the symbol's part in the reuse, recycling and other forms of recovery of electro waste.
Furthermore, they are to state potential adverse effects on the environment and human health which may occur due to the presence of hazardous substances.


Information for treatment facilities

In accordance with Article 11 of the WEEE Directive, manufacturers shall supply information which facilitates the reuse and an adequate, ecologically sound treatment of waste electrical and electronic equipment, which encompasses maintenance, upgrade, refurbishment and recycling. Producers must provide details as to the various components and materials contained in a product and specify the parts which contain hazardous substances and preparations.